Comparing PageSpeed Insights vs Pingdom? Learn which gives accurate results. (2025)
Which Google actually cares about, and when to use both tools.
See Our PageSpeed Tests For Yourself. (Then Scroll Down).
Updated 22nd November 2025
This post compares real PageSpeed Insights results in 2025.
Along with Pingdom’s scoring, it shows which tool gives more accurate data.
Run a Google PageSpeed Test for Your Website (Free Tool Below)
⚠️MOST WEBSITES SCORE UNDER 50
HOW ABOUT YOURS?
✅ Independently verified by Google PageSpeed
Try a FREE website speed check below
🔗 TEST YOUR SITE SPEED NOW
**PSI is a testing tool, not an endorsement.**
A genuine endorsement of our performance work
You can read the official WPX appraisal below.
WPX APPRAISAL
One Job P/Day =FULL FOCUS
We only take on one website per day, because rushing speed work doesn’t cut it.
Your site gets our full focus, and every detail is tuned for performance.
This hands-on approach consistently alters your scores to green on PSI. It boosts Google rankings.
It helps you attract more traffic, more visibility, and ultimately, more business.
However, the good news is that once you know how to use Google PageSpeed Insights properly,
You’ll uncover exactly what’s dragging your site down and how to fix it for good.
Afterwards, look at the homepage and check out the full service that delivers these kinds of results shown on the “Live Results” page. (Updated Daily)
You pay upfront, and we do the work fast.
There are no hidden costs.
✅ Mobile-first
✅ Core Web Vitals fixed
✅ Google Green scores achieved
✅ Before & after proof
✅ 100% UK-based, WordPress-only service
✔️ GREEN SCORES, OR YOUR MONEY BACK✔️
“Can you guarantee I’ll get green PageSpeed Insights scores?”
Without a doubt, we guarantee a significant speed boost.
Most clients achieve scores of 90–100 on Google PageSpeed Insights.
If we fail to deliver green results across the core metrics, you’ll receive a full refund.
Our daily proof results reinforce these real scores.
The Better Of The Two Tools
Although you must learn how to use PageSpeed Insights here, it is the better of the two tools.
Use Pingdom for waterfall and seeing heavy requests.
In this guide, we show what each measures, what reflects real speed, and exactly when to use each.
We Compared PageSpeed Tests So You Don’t Have To
We’ve also compared PageSpeed Insights with other popular speed tools – check them out below:
Firstly, PageSpeed Insights: Mobile vs Desktop
Then
PageSpeed Insights vs DebugBear
Then
Also
PageSpeed Insights vs WebPageTest
And
PageSpeed Insights vs SpeedVitals
Also
PageSpeed Insights vs Uptrends
As well as
Finally
PageSpeed Insights vs Lighthouse
Let’s break it down and find out why PageSpeed Insights is still the best option in 2025
What is Pingdom?
It is a well-known third-party speed testing platform that provides a performance grade based on:
Why it matters
Performance on The Pingdom Speed Test
Performance Grade:- 96 (A)
Page Size: 412.4 KB
Load Time: 704ms
Requests: 20
TEST YOUR SITE WITH PINGDOM NOW
The link to the PINGDOM tool.
What is Google PageSpeed Insights?
We used these to get our results. (Look at our live results in the main menu.)
💡 Every 100/100 result you see here runs on WPX Hosting.
We’ve tested dozens of providers, and WPX is the only one.
The only one that consistently gives the speed foundation for,
Proven Green Google PageSpeed Insights scores.
For the best chance of matching our results, we strongly recommend them.
👉 Check out WPX Hosting here (Affiliate link)
Why it matters
Difference Between PageSpeed Insights vs Pingdom
When it comes to measuring website performance,
PageSpeed Insights and Pingdom serve different, but equally important purposes.
PageSpeed Insights, built by Google, is tightly integrated with Core Web Vitals.
That means it directly impacts your SEO.
It provides both lab and field data, analysing metrics like performance, accessibility, best practices, and SEO.
This makes it a go-to for ranking improvements.
Pingdom, on the other hand, focuses purely on user experience.
It tests real-world load times from different global locations.
This will give you a snapshot of how fast your site feels to actual users.
You’ll receive metrics such as total page size and the number of requests.
Also, there are detailed waterfalls that show where time is being spent.
The key difference? PSI helps you align with Google’s expectations.
Pingdom shows how your site performs in the wild.
Use PSI for compliance and rankings, and Pingdom to ensure your visitors aren’t left waiting around.
Smart developers use both because they complement each other well.
There is also another speed testing tool called DEBUGBEAR. Read our comparison of PageSpeed Insights vs DebugBear right here.
PageSpeed Insights vs Pingdom: Which Speed Test Should You Trust?
When it comes to optimising your WordPress site, two tools dominate the conversation.
Google PageSpeed Insights (PSI) and Pingdom Tools. But which one matters more?
Which gives you actionable data you can use? And, perhaps most importantly,
Which one do your potential customers care about?
AGAIN
Google says we’re technically perfect.
Pingdom says we’re lightning fast in practice.
So what’s the difference, and which one matters?
Key Differences Between PageSpeed Insights and Pingdom
| Feature | PageSpeed Insights | Pingdom |
|---|---|---|
| Owned by Google | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| SEO Impact | ✅ Direct (Core Web Vitals) | ❌ None |
| Uses Real User Data | ✅ Yes (if available) | ❌ No |
| Load Time Measurement | ❌ Not primary focus | ✅ Main metric |
| Page Size & Requests | ❌ Limited info | ✅ Detailed |
| Test Locations | ❌ Fixed (usually US) | ✅ Multiple (global) |
| Trusted by SEOs | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Trusted by Devs | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
Answers To Some FAQs About PSI vs Pingdom
Which is better, PageSpeed Insights or Pingdom?
PageSpeed Insights is better for SEO because it measures Core Web Vitals,
This is what Google uses as ranking signals.
Also, Pingdom is useful for analysing waterfalls, requests, and server performance.
Many developers use both together.
Does Google use Pingdom scores for SEO?
No, Google does not use Pingdom scores for SEO.
Google only uses Core Web Vitals from PageSpeed Insights and real user data in Chrome User Experience reports.
Pingdom is still helpful for debugging speed issues.
Why are my PageSpeed Insights scores different from Pingdom?
The tools measure different things. PageSpeed Insights focuses on,
Core Web Vitals (LCP, CLS, and INP) and SEO-related performance.
Pingdom measures requests, waterfall loading, and raw speed from global test servers.
This is why scores often differ.
Should I use both PageSpeed Insights and Pingdom together?
Yes. PageSpeed Insights tells you how your site performs on Google’s Core Web Vitals.
It affects SEO rankings. Pingdom will help you discover technical bottlenecks,
Such as slow scripts, large images, or server delays.
Using the two gives you a complete picture of speed and performance.
Final Verdict
If you’re serious about WordPress speed optimisation (and you should be),
There’s no need to pick sides. These tools complement each other perfectly.
PSI ensures your site matches Google’s standards,
While Pingdom ensures it’s blazing fast where it matters: In front of real people.
At Green PageSpeed, we obsess over both.
That’s how we deliver lightning-fast, technically flawless websites that not only rank well,
But feel incredible to your users.
Do you want your own site to have green scores like ours?
Read our Green PageSpeed Insights proof post here.